A high-quality spring mattress offers an impressive balance of support and comfort to a broad range of sleeping styles and body types, comes with a long risk-free trial period, and provides excellent edge support and motion isolation.
The Saatva Classic Mattress is our top pick because you can try it for 120 nights, there are three firmness options, and the company offers free in-home set-up and mattress removal.
For the best foundation for your new spring mattress, check out our guide to the best bed frames.
A mattress is one of the most important purchases you’ll make in your lifetime. After all, a significant amount of our time is spent sleeping. But with so many different mattress options, where do you start?
If you’re leaning toward a traditional spring mattress (also called an innerspring mattress), we have five great recommendations, including our favorite, the Saatva Classic.
What to look for in a spring mattress
With next-gen memory foam tech generating all the latest mattress buzz, why pick one with springs? Don’t think of those uncomfortable spring mattresses from the past. Today’s options are well-made, comfortable to sleep on, and designed to last for some time (at least, at the higher end). Compared to a foam mattress, a spring mattress offers better air circulation, edge support, and bounce. It can also feel plusher.
Firmness: Your sleeping style and body types will determine what firmness is ideal for you. For the most part, heavier individuals and back sleepers will benefit most from a firmer mattress. Lighter folks and those who sleep on their side or stomach will prefer mattresses on the softer side. Of course, there is also variance due to preference within each of these categories.
Motion isolation: This is a must if you are a light sleeper and share a bed with a partner or pets. Edge support is another important feature for couples because you don’t want to feel like you’re going to fall off when your significant other decides to annex your side of the bed.
Foundation: Spring mattresses work best on a firm, supportive foundation. When I’m testing mattresses, I keep them on the floor, which works perfectly fine. However, this makes it harder to get in and out of bed, and your mattress may soak up any spills nearby, which could cause permanent damage. So, we recommend using a bed frame or foundation. Here are the best options we’ve tested.
While everyone has a budget in mind, price shouldn’t be your main consideration when buying a spring mattress since you will be using this mattress for 10 years or longer. So, differences in prices work out to only a few cents per day. Additionally, most mattress retailers offer financing options, although we don’t recommend going into debt if you can avoid it.
How to test a mattress
A comfortable mattress for one person may be torture for another. So, the only way to know for sure that a bed will be right for your sleeping style and body type is to sleep on it. Most online companies offer risk-free trials — the brands featured in our guide have trials of at least 100 nights, including two with 365-night trials. However, be sure to read the fine print because some companies will charge you shipping fees or other expenses if you want to return a mattress.
Here are the best spring mattresses:
Best overall: Saatva Classic Mattress
Best organic: Avocado Green Mattress
Best motion isolation: DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress
Best for hot sleepers: Leesa Hybrid Mattress
Best from a traditional manufacturer: Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Performance Copper II Plush Mattress
Prices and links are current as of 8/5/20. We added additional information to guide you on how to shop for a mattress. SEE ALSO: The best mattresses you can buy
The best overall
The Saatva Classic Mattress is designed to suit a variety of sleeping styles and features a plush top for luxurious comfort.
The Saatva Classic Mattress is all about options and convenience. In addition to six standard mattress sizes, you can choose between three firmness levels (luxury firm, plush soft, and firm) and two thicknesses (11.5 inches and 14.5 inches). There’s also a foundation, frame, and adjustable base that go with the mattress.
The individual pocket coils provide excellent support to the very edge of the mattress. And, the different firmness levels ensure that you will be comfortable no matter your sleeping style. You can try the mattress for 120 nights, and if you don’t like it, return it for a refund (minus a $99 transportation fee). The bed also has a 15-year warranty.
Insider Reviews’ Kylie Joyner tested the Saatva Classic Mattress and loved the “Goldilocks” combination of comfort and support. Since sleeping on the luxury firm mattress, she and her partner have experienced decreased back pain. She was also able to sleep easy knowing that Saatva makes their mattresses in the United States using environmentally-friendly materials.
Pros: 120-night trial, nice bounce, plush softness, three firmness levels, free in-home delivery and mattress removal
Cons: Not ideal for people over 200 pounds, fees associated with returns
Read our review of the Saatva Mattress
The best organic
The Avocado Green Mattress is made of organic certified latex, wool, and cotton using carbon-neutral practices and is backed by a 25-year warranty.
The Avocado Green Mattress is billed as a “natural” mattress because it’s made of GOLS organic certified Dunlop latex rubber foam, GOTS organic certified cotton, and GOTS organic certified New Zealand wool. There are also up to 1,414 individually-wrapped pocket coils.
The Avocado bed is firmer than most, but you can use the Euro pillow-top version for two extra inches of latex foam, which gives it a more medium firmness. There’s also a Vegan Mattress alternative that doesn’t use wool.
The mattress comes with an impressive one-year trial period, and if you decide you don’t like it, you get a full refund. Shipping is free, but it costs an extra $199 if you want the pros to set the mattress up and remove your old bed.
Pros: One-year risk-free trial, 25-year warranty, made of natural materials, durable, comfortable and supportive for a broad range of sleeping styles
Cons: Questionable motion isolation
The best for motion isolation
If you share a bed, the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress is a smart choice because it controls motion transfer so you don’t wake up when your partner moves around.
The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress consists of eight layers, including a durable quilted Euro-top, gel-infused memory foam contour and comfort layer, support layer, pocketed innerspring coils, and a base support layer. There’s also a bottom mattress cover that keeps the mattress stable. At 15 inches, the mattress is thicker than most, which tends to equate to better comfort but can make it hard for keeping fitted sheets on.
DreamCloud offers a 365-night risk-free trial, and the mattress is backed by a lifetime warranty.
Insider Reviews’ Lulu Chang tested out the DreamCloud mattress and found it blew away the all-foam options. She noted that the eight-layer hybrid system offered unparalleled support. She was also impressed with how breathable and soft the bed is.
Pros: Excellent motion isolation, ideal for back and stomach sleepers, 365-night trial, lifetime warranty
Cons: Complaints of subpar customer service and long-term odors
Read our review of the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress
The best for hot sleepers
The Leesa Hybrid Mattress is ideal for a broad range of sleeping styles, heavier people, and those of us who tend to get hot in the night.
Formerly known as the “Sapira,” the Leesa Hybrid Mattress is what my wife and I sleep on when I’m not testing other models. I’ve tested more than a dozen mattresses, and this is the most comfortable for my 6-foot, 250-pound side- and stomach-sleeping frame and my wife’s tall, weight-proportional back-sleeping body. In most beds, I tend to overheat, but this hybrid does a spectacular job of dissipating that heat so I can stay cool all night.
The bed passed the motion transfer tests I put it through, and the edge support is outstanding, which makes it perfect for couples. Leesa lets you try the mattress for 100 nights risk-free, and it’s backed by a 10-year warranty.
Pros: Great edge support, impressive motion isolation, dissipates heat, works for a variety of sleeping styles
Cons: Too firm for some, especially petite side sleepers
Read our review of the Leesa Hybrid Mattress
The best from a traditional maker
If you are looking for a satisfying spring mattress from a company with a long track record, the Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Performance Copper II Plush Mattress is your best bet.
Despite the rise of the bed-in-a-box industry, Sealy, Simmons, and Serta continue to be the big three mattress manufacturers. Each has been around for over 80 years, while many of the big-name mattress start-ups disrupting the industry have less than a decade under their belt. Therefore, we thought it best to include a mattress from a company that has been around longer than its warranty period.
The Sealy Posturepedic Hybrid Performance Copper II Plush Mattress combines contouring memory foam with supportive pocket coils. The quilted mattress top is designed to wick moisture. And, there’s a 2-inch gel memory foam top layer to keep you cool. Altogether, the mattress sports a comforting 13.5 inches of encased coils and memory foam padding and support.
You can test out the mattress risk-free for 120 nights, and if you decide to keep it, it’s backed by a 10-year warranty.
Pros: Comfortable and supportive for back and side sleepers of all sizes, great edge support and motion transfer control, 120-night trial
Cons: Too soft for some stomach sleepers
What else we considered
Aviya: Many expert sites recommend the Aviya mattress. And, it’s easy to see why. The bed is made in the USA of CertiPUR-USA-approved foams and locally-sourced materials. It’s also available in three firmness levels – plush, firm, and luxury firm – so you can choose an alternative that’s right for you. You get to try the bed for 100 nights risk-free. Unfortunately, there are complaints of even the firm mattresses not being firm enough. And, the customer service is questionable.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature: Brooklyn Bedding sells six different mattress styles, and any of them will serve you well. The Signature mattress is available in three firmness levels and can be tried with a 120-night risk-free trial. It didn’t make our guide because there weren’t enough positive expert reviews and some buyers complain that the mattress traps heat.
Simmons Beautyrest Platinum Phillipsburg III Luxury Firm: This is our runner-up for the best spring mattress from a traditional manufacturer. The Beautyrest name has been synonymous with high-quality mattresses for decades. This 14-inch-thick mattress features gel memory foam layers, comfort foam, pocket coils, and cool ventilation. It didn’t make our list because there was a lack of consensus among expert reviewers.
Nest Alexander Signature Hybrid: The Alexander Signature Hybrid from Nest Bedding is 13.5-inches thick and is designed for cool comfort. It features a gel-infused memory foam top layer, three inches of TitanChill endurance foam, SmartFlow support foam, pocket coils, and base support foam.
Helix Midnight: This model is more affordable than any of the other options on our list, yet it still has a nice 100-night risk-free trial, comes with two pillows, and is made of high-quality CertiPUR-US certified materials. However, there are a few customers who have complained about the mattress trapping heat and not providing enough support.
Check out our other great sleep guides
The best mattresses
If you find that a spring mattress isn’t right for you after all, we’ve tested dozens of mattresses to bring you our recommendations for the best ones on the market. Check out our larger guide to the best mattresses.
The best pillows
A good pillow means a good night’s sleep. We tested dozens of pillows to narrow down the choices to the ones you’ll love best. From down pillows to memory foam and everything in between, here are the best pillows you can buy.
The best sheets
Few would deny that at the end of a long, hard day, sliding into a comfortable bed outfitted with soft, smooth sheets that pamper your skin is one of life’s greatest pleasures. After reviewing dozens of contenders for the best sheets, we’ve narrowed it down to our favorites.
The best mattress toppers
Although a mattress topper isn’t a must-have for your bed, it’s one of the easiest ways to up your sleep quality and comfort. We tested and researched dozens of mattress toppers and determined that these are our favorites.